Molly Holly, only because I haven't seen more than maybe 3 or 4 Aja kong matches. I do like what I've seen though, but I've always been a Miss Madness mark.
Ayako Hamada. It's hard to say though because I think both are vastly overrated as ring workers.
Gail Kim. Nattie has this whole hype surrounding her from the indies that she never lived up to in my eyes. Gail's headlined shows in 5 star matches.
Taylor Wilde, but it's a close one. Beth's probably the better all around worker considering people sometimes couldn't work Taylor's speed, but when she was in there with the right woman she was great. I guess the edge goes to looks. I'd do miserable things to Taylor Wilde
Melina. Angelina wrestles like a top WWE Diva, whereas Melina usually puts top WWE Divas to shame.
Velvet Sky. This was tough, because I do like McCool, but i think they're about on the same level wrestling wise, so Sky gets the edge with looks...and that butt pop she does when she enters the ring.
AJ Lee. AJ can wrestle.
Cheerleader Melissa. I've seen Melissa wrestle better than most men in the WWE. Jazz is an awesome talent with a great look though.
Sarita. I was never a huge Madusa fan
Sara Del Rey. I've only seen so much Faby. I hear both Apaches are great though, and from what I've seen, they are.
Eve Torres. She's probably the best Diva wrestling right now. I've even heard Shimmer's Allison Danger oogle over her on podcasts on multiple occasions, wishing she'd get released just so she can get her for Shimmer.
Victoria. Lita was a spot monkey, and probably had one of the worst moonsaults ever. Victoria's almost a perfectionist in the ring.
Awesome Kong. I've seen a lot of Toyota, and none of it's lived up to the hype for me yet. She's got some great moves, but doesn't string them together well in my opinion. Kong is...well, Kong.
I'd probably say Shimmer simply because I'm more familiarized. I've seen AAA, I've seen Joshi leagues, and I've seen a majority of the girls in Women Superstars Uncensored wrestle and the truth of the matter is, the cream of the crop usually ends up in Shimmer. I have a strong admiration for what Allison and Dave Prazak are doing for women's wrestling.
I do agree with that sentiment wholeheartedly, and I think most of them do after they earn it on the indies and in TNA, but I don't know if things will ever be like that in the WWE.